Hockey Patrol has no direct affiliation to the Toronto Maple Leafs, NHL or NHLPA
HOCKEY PATROL  |  NHL  |  TRADES

Trade Proposal Sends Two Star Defensemen To The Toronto Maple Leafs


PUBLICATION
Tyler Ball
February 21, 2024  (7:03 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY

NHL defenseman Matt Dumba and NHL defenseman Chris Tanev playing hockey
Photo credit: Sporting News

A new mock trade has surfaced today put together by The Athletic. The wild 3-team trade scenario would land the Toronto Maple Leafs two different star defensemen for the rest of the season.

Wild 3 Team Mock Trade Lands The Maple Leafs Major Defensive Help

It is widely known that the Toronto Maple Leafs have struggled to find consistency on defense this season. Whether through injury, suspensions, or just poor play the Maple Leafs defense needs an upgrade. Today a mock trade put together by The Athletic solves this issue for Toronto.
In the mock trade, the Maple Leafs do some nifty maneuvering in a three-team trade and land a pair of star-level defensemen. In the trade, they would be dealing with the Arizona Coyotes and the Calgary Flames. In the end, the Maple Leafs would acquire defensemen Matt Dumba and Chris Tanev.
«Arizona Coyotes trade Matt Dumba and a 2024 second-round draft choice to the Maple Leafs for Toronto's 2024 first-rounder. Toronto flips the second-rounder to the Calgary Flames for Chris Tanev.»
This trade would require the Maple Leafs to part with their first-round pick but honestly would not cost them all that much.

Analyzing The Maple Leafs Blockbuster Mock Trade

Heading into the trade deadline many fans are hoping that the Maple Leafs pull off a blockbuster and bring in a star. In the case of this trade, Toronto would bring in two very well-known names.
In the first part of this deal, the Maple Leafs land Matt Dumba and a second-round pick from the Arizona Coyotes for the Maple Leafs first-round pick.
image
With the 29-year-old Dumba struggling mightily in his first year in Arizona the Coyotes might look to move on from him for cheap. While a first-round pick isn't cheap on its own getting back a second-rounder makes it look a lot more enticing. Dumba has struggled in a big role in Arizona but could thrive in a reduced role on a better team in Toronto.
The second part of this deal would involve the Maple Leafs sending the second-round pick from Arizona to the Calgary Flames for Chris Tanev.
image
At this point giving up only a second-round pick for Chris Tanev would be considered a bargain with where his value is at. The 34-year-old would immediately slot into the Maple Leafs top four and be a key upgrade for the Maple Leafs.
If both of these moves are pulled off the Maple Leafs would walk away with two prestigious defensemen with top-four upside for only a first and a second-round pick. This would be a huge move by Brad Treliving and place the Maple Leafs in the Stanley Cup favorite category.
POLL
FEVRIER 21|797 ANSWERS
Trade Proposal Sends Two Star Defensemen To The Toronto Maple Leafs

Who wins this trade?

Toronto Maple Leafs59174.2 %
Arizona Coyotes9411.8 %
Calgary Flames11214.1 %
List of polls

HOCKEY PATROL
COPYRIGHT @2026 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE - PRIVACY POLICY - COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED - SITEMAP - ROBOTS.TXT