The Scott Laughton trade is biting the Maple Leafs now as he is getting much more usage in Los Angeles and could have prevented their goaltending fiasco.
When the Maple Leafs acquired Scott Laughton from the Philadelphia Flyers, it cost them Nikita Grebenkin and a first-round pick. He was expected to shore up the bottom-six as a two-way support piece that could provide a little bit of everything.
But instead, he lasted 63 games, was shipped out unceremoniously at the trade deadline and the kicker? The team barely got a return for him. While it did turn out to be a fruitful pick as it led to Alexander Bilecki, you wonder if they would be better off with Laughton.
Scott Laughton trade had an unforeseen domino effect for the Maple Leafs
The whole goal of the Toronto Maple Leafs this past offseason was revamping the bottom-six and they spent heavily on the likes of Colton Sissons, Teddy Blueger, Brandon Duhaime, and Zack MacEwen.
Laughton would have basically been a free upgrade to that revamped bottom-six without the need to splurge in the offseason, and he was a player willing to stick around considering how much he loved his short time with the team.
Laughton, 32, had eight ppiints in 21 games for the Kings last year and has 6 points in 19 games this season. The offense isn't eye-popping but he is winning 57% of his face-offs, and has 50 hits.
Considering that Laughton signed for only $3.5M - basically what the team spent on Blueger and MacEwen - he would have fit in financially, and provided a lot more value overall to the lineup by proxy of being a Swiss Army knife of sorts.
Toronto's goaltender situation could have been avoided had Laughton stayed
Plus, the one factor that can't be ignored is that Laughton sticking around may not have led to the Nick Paul trade and therefore - Dennis Hildeby still being a Maple Leaf.
If that was the case then this whole goaltender fiasco could be fixed as the team could sit Bobrovsky and have Anthony Stolarz and Hildeby take the reins. Instead, the team is struggling for goaltender help and have a clogged up bottom-six.
Plus, Laughton offers exactly the same style of play as Paul. He's defensively sound, elite at face-offs, is a penalty killing maestro, but also comes with the added benefit of being a genuinely good offensive contributor.
There is a world where Laughton doesn't get sent to the Kings and decides to re-up with the Maple Leafs.
But that's one in a parallel universe, and one that Toronto wishes they found themselves in - not the current horror show they're living right now.
Do you think the Maple Leafs made a mistake trading Scott Laughton?
Also read on Hockey Patrol :
Maple Leafs reportedly walking on eggshells around William Nylander