Trading Auston Matthews may seem like they've given up, but the Maple Leafs getting a haul for him could be all part of a long-term plan that sees him return in 2028.

A lot of the discussion this past off-season was focused on whether or not the Maple Leafs made the necessary moves to give Auston Matthews enough support while also proving to him they can be competitive.

They've done anything but that recently, and if the team continues to free fall down the standings, it might be a telling sign that things aren't improving - which means Matthews may want out.

Trading him would no doubt bring a haul especially after his resurgence this season, and if the Maple Leafs want to seriously transform their franchise, a trade might be necessary.

Though, it might be the savviest move they'll make.

Maple Leafs could have their cake and eat it too with Auston Matthews

However there is a hidden reason that trading Matthews now while the iron is hot could not only benefit the Maple Leafs now, but also down the line because some believe that just because they traded their captain - doesn't mean he won't return:

There is a genuine chance that the team ships Matthews off this season (or this summer) and get all the necessary pieces back to accelerate a rebuild: a franchise defenseman, young NHL-ready prospects, premium draft assets and the like.

Well, once Toronto has those and put forth a genuine change in their lineup, what's to stop Matthews from simply resigning back in 2028? He's going to be a free agent, and there is potential for a plan to be in place to bring him back after they make the moves they need.

If the team approaches him and says 'We aren't winning now, but you can get us what we need to do so,' then it might give him a reason to accept a trade while also knowing full well that he wants to be the one who wins in Toronto.

Matthews wants to win in Toronto, and shows he's willing to be patient

For all intents and purposes, Matthews doesn't want to leave and no matter how bad things have gotten he's never demanded out or been a cause for concern.

He loves the city and loves the team, and it's hard to see that suddenly evaporating - especially if there's a better chance of winning in a couple years.

By the time Matthews is a free agent, the team will have a boatload of cap and a ton of contract space to go for broke and not only bring in Matthews, but also add some tantalizing free agent names who could be on the market like Ivan Barbashev or Clayton Keller (one of Matthews' closest friends).

If the Maple Leafs look a lot more put together, have a proper system in place, and genuinely make strides at getting younger and faster on the blue line and not overspending on aging veterans? Matthews could very well return.

You may as well trade him away while his value is at its peak, because it might be the only way to bring him back at the end of the day.

POLL

Should the Maple Leafs trade Auston Matthews with the risk he may not return in free agency?

Also read on Hockey Patrol :
Maple Leafs reportedly walking on eggshells around William Nylander