The injury history is undeniable, but so is the body of work. Among active goalies with at least 400 games on their career resume, Andersen's .916 save percentage in 511 contests is the fourth-best mark in the league.
The only goalies with superior marks - and it's just by a tick - are three guys with .917 SPs. They are megastars
Connor Hellebuyck and
Andrei Vasilevskiy, as well as sneaky-good
Semyon Varlamov.
Also, how about this for consistency: In 125 games with Anaheim, Andersen had a .918 SP, then he went .914 in 268 games with the Leafs before posting a .918 in 118 contests with the Canes. Andersen is on a real heater right now, too, going 5-1-0 in his past half dozen showings with a .939 SP.
You're not tapping him for 55 starts - especially since he turns 36 in October - but the big Dane knows how to stop a puck.