Maple Leafs May Be Forced to let William Nylander Walk in Free Agency
The Nylander situation is getting harder to handle, and it's becoming an increasingly better option to let him walk in free agency.
Nylander's Future
Nylander has confirmed that he wants to stay in Toronto. Now, ultimately that has to work for the team as well, and with Matthews signing an extension, the cap room for Nylander continues to shrink.
The Leafs seem to have the following options:
1. Re-sign him to a team-friendly contract
2. Trade him for an elite-defenseman and win the trade
3. Re-sign him to a fair contract
4. Trade him in trade that doesn't make current team worse.
5. Re-sign him to a player-friendly expensive contract
6. Let him walk for nothing, but keep him for one more year
7. Make a good trade for the future that hurts the team right now
8. Make a bad trade right now
As time passes, options 1-3 are getting more and more unlikely. Option 4 could occur, but the bar for a "fair trade" is pretty high, as the Leafs would need to get at least Nylander's value back, and more, since they already know Nylander's current contract for this year is a steal.
So... Let Him Walk?
The biggest mistake the Leafs could make is trading Nylander for the sake of trading him and losing one of the best contracts they have. They also continue to be on the cusp of a Stanley Cup run, so a future-oriented trade isn't the best for the team as well.
Letting Nylander walk would allow the Leafs to take another good stab at the Cup with an extremely valuable Nylander contract as a "rental".
As read on Editor in Leaf - "Toronto Maple Leafs: Letting Nylander Walk Maybe Better Than Trade"
POLL |
Should the Leafs let Nylander Walk? |
Yes | 380 | 38.7 % |
No | 601 | 61.3 % |
List of polls |
|
1 hour ago | By Chris Gerics Update on Sean Durzi's Injury Should Kickstart Utah HC's Trade Talks With the Toronto Maple Leafs |
|
3 hours ago | By Daniel Lucente Arber Xhekaj Sends a Clear Warning to the Rangers and Jacob Trouba Following the Hit on Justin Barron |
|
3 hours ago | By Chris Gerics Toronto Maple Leafs Insider Gives Update Regarding Max Pacioretty's Injury Status |
|
4 hours ago | By Daniel Lucente John Tortorella at the Center of Pressing Issues in Philadelphia |
|
4 hours ago | By Chris Gerics NHL's Punishment Problem: George Parros' Anti-Leafs Bias and Inconsistent Rulings in the Case of Ekman-Larsson |
|
5 hours ago | By Chris Gerics Two-Time Stanley Cup Champion Conor Sheary Placed On Waivers In Shocking Move |
|
6 hours ago | By Chris Gerics The NHL Makes a Decision on Max Domi's Questionable Punch to the Back of the Head of Adam Fantilli |
|
7 hours ago | By Chris Gerics Maple Leafs Are on the Verge of Making a Major Mistake with Matthew Knies |
Previously on HockeyPatrol