The Maple Leafs face a big decision over Joe Bowen's successor

Joe Bowen was the voice of the Maple Leafs for 44 years and with his retirement, and Toronto's radio partners are left needing to find his replacement.

If you were to ask most Maple Leafs fans what 'Holy Mackinaw' meant, they'd no doubt point to Joe Bowen's iconic call during intense or emotional moments. Spending over 40 years as the broadcaster for Toronto's radio and television broadcasts, Bowen is as synonymous with the team as any of its players.

But 2025-26 was his final year in the booth, with the team celebrating his legacy during 'Holy Mackinaw Night' on December 16 and giving him his own evening of festivities that included alumni, special tributes, and a highlight of all of Bowen's calls throughout the years.

His voice was legendary and a huge part of the Maple Leafs' identity, so with him retiring and moving on, both Sportsnet 590 The FAN and TSN 1050 have to decide who is best to replace him - not an easy task in the slightest.

Toronto has only a few weeks to choose the voice to replace Joe Bowen

With training camp on the horizon and the preseason starting Sept. 19, Toronto's need for a radio broadcaster grows larger and there has yet to be a public announcement regarding a replacement for Bowen. There is a possibility the Bowen name continues on, with Joe's son David also being a radio broadcaster for the Sudbury Wolves.

The two even had a chance to call a game together, which Joe called 'one of the proudest days of his life'. There's nothing that's indicating that David could be line to replace his dad, but if the Maple Leafs wanted to continue the lineage they have an avenue.

There are also prior broadcasters who used to call Maple Leafs broadcasts such as Dennis Beyak who could get consideration given his familiarity calling games with the team and has worked with Jim Ralph - Bowen's long-time colour commentator however he retired in 2024 so it's not guaranteed he's interested in returning.

But the closer the preseason and opening night approaches, the need for a new voice gets more urgent and Toronto is going to need to find someone who can relay the game with as much knowledge and passion as Bowen did.

The next broadcaster will inherit a job defined by 44 years of passion

This isn't just a new hire or simply a matter of moving on from a particular personality. Bowen was as ingrained in the team as anyone, and he was there through literally everything.

He saw their success in the mid-90s and early 2000s and their drop-off in the late 2000s and 2010s, never missed a game (until last year) and is a legendary broadcaster and received the Foster Hewitt Memorial Award in 2018 for his contributions to broadcasting.

This next voice is going to have big shoes to fill but they have to grow into those shoes with time. Fans are going to take a bit to get used to not only a different voice, but a different atmosphere. Bowen made you feel like you were part of the crowd watching the game, and it's one thing to simply relay the game at hand - it's another to call it so vividly you can feel it.

It's a balancing act between bringing in a person who fans already know but also adding someone who cares and loves the Maple Leafs just as deeply, while also presenting the game in an accessible format no matter who is listening.

Whoever is coming in doesn't just inherit what Bowen brought to the Maple Leafs but they also inherit his responsibility - being the dependable and reliable voice of Toronto hockey for the next 40+ years and their path starts in 2026-27.

Also read on Hockey Patrol :
Arber Xhekaj and Sean Monahan reveal the Maple Leafs identified their roster problem years ago