Former NHL goalie turned anaylst Steven Valiquette warned John Chayka against signing Sergei Bobrovsky but the Maple Leafs GM played ignorant.

There's been a lot of talk about how bad the signing of Sergei Bobrovsky was for the Maple Leafs this past summer. Sure, he had the resume, but was coming off his worst season, was cast out by the Panthers, and then signed a pretty lucrative deal all things considered.

He's failed in his first season as a Maple Leaf though, and John Chayka is getting a lot of deserved flak for putting all his eggs in the Bobrovsky basket without having a bit of foresight in case it went south.

Toronto was warned about Bobrovsky but chose blissful ignorance instead

Well, it turns out that not only did Chayka have the benefit of foresight, but he had genuine numbers and stats to back up why it was a bad decision - and he decided to ignore it.

Former NHL goalie Steve Valiquette revealed that he personally sent a memo with several readouts explaining how Bobrovsky was doomed to fail, and that it wasn't just a one off bad season in 2025-26 but a serious sign of regression:

What we've found over the last 12 years at Clear Sight is that at age 38, that's the major decline risk signal, and for older goalies, minus-15 is often the beginning of structural decline.

Once older goalies fall below that minus-15 line, recovery becomes much less likely at this age. A poor season is more often a structural decline, and it's a strong signal that this isn't just a short-term performance dip.

For reference, Bobrovsky was a minus-22 last season, which was the worst in the entire NHL. Valiquette also explained that his memo went out to all GMs and that Chayka indeed got one too - even if he didn't end up ever actually reading it:

I know the Leafs received this report that I put together before free agency, and I don't know if Chayka got it. I don't know, I just know that this found a way into management.

If that's the case, then it's a poor case of management in the front office and whoever got the memo and didn't pass it along deserves more than a slap on the wrist.

The person to blame isn't John Chayka, but Mats Sundin

Unfortunately, that person may be someone who is endeared by the Maple Leafs fans and loved by all - Mats Sundin.

It's no secret and has been officially confirmed that Bobrovsky was a Sundin decision, as Chayka reportedly wanted to focus on things up front before doing any work in the crease - a non-factor at that point.

Way back on Oct. 5th, it was revealed as well that Sundin believed that Bobrovsky could be what Ed Belfour was to him 20 years ago - but Belfour and Bobrovsky are two different beasts and played in two completely different eras.

Also, let's not forget that Belfour actually had competent defenders in front of him like Bryan McCabe, Tomas Kaberle, Pavel Kubina, Aki Berg, Brian Leetch and Jyrki Lumme.

Bobrovsky is relying on depth players like Dakota Mermis and past their prime defensemen like Chris Tanev and Oliver Ekman-Larsson. He's got nowhere near as much help and it shows in his numbers.

John Chayka seemed to have missed the memo that Valiquette sent out, but perhaps it was intercepted before he could reach it. That way, Sundin could have an easier way of persuading Chayka to sign Bobrovsky.

If so, while we can point the finger at Chayka for pulling the trigger we also need to look at who was pulling the strings.

POLL

Was signing Sergei Bobrovsky a bad idea for the Maple Leafs?

Also read on Hockey Patrol :
Maple Leafs make drastic yet necessary decision involving Sergei Bobrovsky