The Maple Leafs made several major moves this summer, but the blockbuster trade that dominated so much of the speculation never came to be.
John Chayka needs to be commended for doing what he set out to do, which is to add where the Maple Leafs were the weakest, while also preparing himself up nicely for the future of the team after the 2026 NHL Draft.
They also managed to raise quite a stir when they signed Sergei Bobrovsky to a $21M deal, and acquired Darren Raddysh in a $68M sign-and-trade with the Tampa Bay Lightning.
However, fan confidence is still lagging behind other teams, and while there is a lot to be excited for when it comes to the team, there are still some potential concerns regarding how the offence is going to play out especially with regard to where Gavin McKenna is going to fit in.
Toronto's options disappeared one by one this summer
But their lack of confidence may be also due to the fact they never really made a huge splash.
Toronto explored several different paths this summer, from adding a high-end defenceman to finding another top-six forward. None of those bigger opportunities ultimately became the move that reshaped the roster.
But they were linked to Vincent Trocheck and Adam Fox of the Rangers, Simon Nemec (who was traded to Calgary), Mason Marchment and Jacob Trouba (signed with SJ), Rasmus Andersson (re-signed with Vegas), and Zach Werenski (who stayed in Columbus).
They were also unable to find big trades for players they currently have such as Morgan Rielly, and are still lacking that one final piece to round out their lineup. They tried numerous times to find a deal, and even had one potentially in place with San Jose before they switched gears and pursued Darnell Nurse instead.
The focus was clear from the get-go from Chayka and the rest of the Maple Leafs which was to ensure their defensive side was more mobile and better puck-movers while adding defensively sound role players up front. The concern rather is that Toronto improved its depth and defensive structure more than it improved proven top-end scoring behind Matthews and Nylander.
Chayka reshaped the Maple Leafs without that blockbuster trade however
Though the team never made that gigantic blockbuster deal, they are in a much better position now than they were three months ago.
Toronto finally has a lineup that knows their role and can do it well, with motivated stars and anew coaching staff that is expected to provide a much more exciting and intense brand of hockey compared to the grinding, north-south style of the past two seasons.
While technically you could call Raddysh's trade a blockbuster due to him being traded to Toronto, it was under different circumstances - a sign-and-trade for a player who was expected to test free agency, where Tampa was in a position to gain an asset while losing him as opposed to walking away empty-handed.
This was an offseason that was built around becoming competitive a lot quicker, and the moves made were ones that will make the team a more complete lineup despite the lack of a big star addition up front or another on the blueline. Their lineup is the polar opposite to the one we saw last year, and while there's a lot of turnover - there's hope too.
Chayka never landed the one blockbuster that would have defined Toronto's summer, but he may have built something more useful: a deeper roster with fewer obvious weak spots.
The unanswered question is whether balance can replace the star-level addition the Maple Leafs spent much of the offseason chasing.
What was the Maple Leafs' best offseason transaction?
Also read on Hockey Patrol :
Gavin McKenna's NHL readiness is already being questioned before Maple Leafs camp