Jeff Carter, in the first year of a two-year extension he signed in Pittsburgh, has been tough to watch this year. At 38, he's one of the oldest active skaters in the league, and unfortunately, he's starting to look like it.
As for Brian Dumoulin, the 31-year-old just hasn't been able to pull it all together this season. He is also making a whopping $4.1-million. With Jeff Petry visibly regressing as well, the future of Pittsburgh on D is worrying. Luckily, he's a pending UFA.
Citing Carter's faceoff percentage, and Dumoulin's involvement on plays are both valid points, but the eye test tells a different story.